Author name: Edwin Lee

Edwin is a corporate and technology lawyer. He is also the founder of Edwin Lee & Partners. Edwin has advised a range of companies from technology startups to multinational corporations on a range of matters. In 2020, Edwin was named as a Malaysian Rising Star by Asian Legal Business, a finalist for the Young Lawyer of the Year at the ALB Malaysia Law Awards as well as a lawyer in the annual ALB publication of Asia 40 under 40. View his full profile here.

Edwin Lee
Regulating Online Businesses and Strengthening Consumer Protection Online

Regulating Online Businesses and Strengthening Consumer Protection Online

Starting from 1 July 2013, all online businesses have to comply with the new requirements set out in the Consumer Protection (Electronic Trade Transactions) Regulations 2012 (“Regulations”) made by the Ministry of Domestic Trade, Co-operatives and Consumerism (“MDTCC”) under Section 150 of the Consumer Protection Act 1999 (“CPA”). The Regulations apply to individual person and business that supplies goods or services via a website (for e.g. blog shop, online store) or an online marketplace (for e.g. Groupon, Lelong, eBay, Mudah, Zalora, Lazada)(“Online Business Supplier”), as well as operator of online marketplace (“Online Marketplace Operator”). An ‘online marketplace’ is defined as a website where goods or services are marketed by third parties for the purpose of trade. This definition is so wide that arguably it covers websites that charge the Online Business Supplier a fee or commission as well as those that provide such platform for free. Online Business Supplier The main objective of the Regulations is to promote transparency through full and frank disclosure. An Online Business Supplier needs to disclose the following information on the website or online marketplace where the business is conducted: the business name (either the name of the owner, business or company); the registration number of the business or company, if applicable; the email address and telephone number, or address of the Online Business Supplier; a description of the main characteristics of the goods or services; the full price of the goods or services, including transportation costs, taxes and any other costs; the method of payment; the terms and conditions of the sale; and the estimated time of delivery of the goods or services to the buyer. It is an offence if the Online Business Supplier fails to disclose any of the above information, or if he/it provides false or misleading information. In addition, the Online Business Supplier also needs to provide appropriate means to enable the buyer to rectify any errors prior to the confirmation of the order made by the buyer; and he/it should acknowledge receipt of the order to the buyer without undue delay. Online Marketplace Operator As for the Online Marketplace Operator, he/it is required to take reasonable steps to keep and maintain a record of the names, telephone numbers and addresses of the Online Business Suppliers for a period of two years. Failure to keep and maintain such record is an offence. The intention of this is to make it easier for a buyer to track down the identity of the Online Business Suppliers in the event of loss or fraud. Privacy, Unfair Contract Terms, False or Misleading Advertisement In addition, if the Online Marketplace Operator collects and processes personal data of the online buyers and the Online Business Suppliers, he/it must also comply with the Personal Data Protection Act 2010 (which may come into force by the end of 2013). In this respect, the Online Marketplace Operators are encouraged to have in place privacy policy, privacy statement, notice and consent form on their websites and online marketplaces that are drafted in compliance with the requirements under the Personal Data Protection Act 2010. It should be noted that there is no “one size fits all” type of privacy policy, privacy statement, notice and consent form. Online Marketplace Operators must refrain from slavishly copying privacy policy, privacy statement, notice and consent form found in other websites and online marketplaces without having regard to their specific business nature and needs. Although the Regulations does not define what should be included in the “terms and conditions” of the sale, the terms and conditions must not contain unfair terms, otherwise, the terms and conditions may be declared as unenforceable or void under the CPA. Any Online Business Supplier or Online Marketplace Operator who put up false or misleading advertisement in relation to their goods or services will also be liable under the CPA. A Rising Trend in Online Businesses and Online Frauds Online businesses have been gaining popularity in recent years as they present an alternative choice for shopping for consumers in Malaysia. The proliferation of the Internet, the wider broadband penetration, the growing prevalence of smartphones as well as the convenience of online shopping are amongst the driving forces behind the growth of online businesses. According to the MDTCC’s statistics, 1.1 million people in Malaysia carried out online transactions with businesses worth more than RM1.8 billion in 2010 and the figure is expected to grow to RM5 billion by 2014. There are 600 online companies and 16,405 online businesses currently registered with the Companies Commission of Malaysia. Unfortunately, incidents of online fraud have also been on the rise. The number of online frauds reported in 2011 rose to 1,879 cases as compared to 511 cases in 2009. It has been reported that online fraud is one of the factors that deter people from actively engaging in online transactions. Offences and Penalties Any Online Business Supplier or Online Marketplace Operator who fails to comply with the Regulations will, upon conviction, be fined up to RM50,000 or jail up to 3 years or both, and for a second or subsequent offence the person will be liable to a fine of up to RM100,000 or to imprisonment up to 5 years or both, and for a second or subsequent offence the person will be liable to a fine of up to RM100,000 or to imprisonment up to 5 years or both. If the offence is committed by a company, it will, upon conviction, be liable to a fine of up to RM100,000, and for a second or subsequent offence a fine of up to RM200,000. In addition to the criminal penalties, an aggrieved consumer may also lodge a claim with the Tribunal for Consumer Complaints about civil remedies against unscrupulous online traders. Conclusion The enactment of the Regulations shows the growing concerns that the Government has towards strengthening consumer protection in online business transactions. In fact, in conjunction with the Regulations, the MDTCC has also launched an e-commerce guideline for consumers to avoid the pitfalls

Regulating Online Businesses and Strengthening Consumer Protection Online Read More »

World IP Day 2013 : Creativity and the Next Generation

World IP Day 2013 : Creativity and the Next Generation

On 26 April every year, the intellectual property community around the world celebrates the World Intellectual Property Day (“World IP Day”). World IP Day is celebrated every year to “promote discussion of the role of intellectual property (“IP”) in fostering and encouraging innovation and creativity, and to celebrate the contribution made by innovators and creators to the development of societies across the world”. The World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO) has named the theme of this year’s World IP Day as “Creativity: The Next Generation”, as it wishes to highlight the role that the next generation of visionary innovators and creators will play in shaping and improving the world. “What is the next big thing to come?” has become the hottest technology phrase. It is a known fact that technology moves so fast that today’s technology could become outdated by the time we master it. Some people cannot wait to get their hands on the latest gadgets, some are curious to find out every new development in the market, many want to know how the world will look like in future, what the new innovations that lie beyond us are, and who would create a song that would become the next online sensation after “Gangnam Style”, which went viral and took the world by storm by hitting 1.5 billion views on YouTube. No one would have thought that a mobile phone can actually function as a computer, combining phone, camera, video camera, music player, GPS, word processing and Internet browsing functions into a little device now widely known as a smartphone. Who would have thought that an online social networking website, Facebook, that was developed and launched from a Harvard dormitory room, would become the most visited website attracting more than 1 billion users worldwide. Google recently introduced Google Wallet, which turns your phone into an electronic wallet, where you can make a payment just by tapping your phone against a Near Field Communication (NFC) point of sale terminal at checkout. By 2015, Google plans to launch Google Glass, an eyeglasses-like wearable computer that can interact with the Internet through voice commands. It is also expected that, by 2025, Google driverless cars will hit the road in many major countries. What used to be science fiction that we see in Hollywood movies will soon become reality. The successful take-off of all these inventions and creations can partly be attributed to the protection given to IP rights. IP rights play an important role in stimulating creativity and innovation, which in turn leads to economic, cultural and social advancement. IP protection also encourages the dissemination of knowledge and provides a guarantee of source and quality to consumers. Different types of IP are protected in different ways, for example, literature and arts such as books, music, films and software are protected as copyright; technological inventions are protected by patent rights; distinctive brands that distinguish one product or service from another are protected through trademark rights; while the unique design or external appearance of objects are protected via industrial design rights. The IP rights framework provides incentives and motivation to innovators and creators to invest time, resources and creative thinking into producing new inventions. Without IP protection, there would be no incentives for film makers to make excellent movies; for artists to produce vibrant music; for inventors to invent new innovative products; or for scientists to develop life-saving drugs that can improve and save millions of lives. Exclusive patent rights are granted to the inventors for a certain period of time in exchange for full disclosure of their inventions and technologies which in turn encourage others to continue to innovate and develop existing products. Studies have also shown that countries with strong IP frameworks and protection experience the greatest innovation, creativity and economic growth. South Korea is a good example. Samsung has now become a household name and a dominant player in the electronic industry. There are millions of fans of K-Pop culture around the world. According to the World Bank’s statistics, South Korea’s GDP per capita has grown from USD$2,000 in 1970 to USD$32,000 in 2012. Ideas matter. Thomas Edison invented and developed, amongst others, the phonograph, motion picture camera and a long lasting electric light bulb that greatly influenced life around the world. Vaccinations have saved the lives of hundreds of millions of people. Music now forms an integral part of our lives. Today, some 2 billion people are connected on the Internet for work, play, communication and entertainment. All these technologies, inventions and creations have had a profound impact on many peoples’ lives. They all stem from someone having a visionary or creative idea to shape and improve the world The future, therefore, lies in the hands of the next generation, and it is hoped that the next generation will make the best use of all these technologies to change the world for the better, and the benefit of humanity. ***** About the author: This article was written by Edwin Lee, Founder and Managing Partner of Edwin Lee & Partners, a law firm in Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia (+6011 5954 1201, [email protected]). Feel free to contact him if you have any queries. This article was first published in CHIP Magazine Malaysia. The view expressed in this article is intended to provide a general guide to the subject matter and does not constitute professional legal advice. You are advised to seek proper legal advice for your specific situation.

World IP Day 2013 : Creativity and the Next Generation Read More »

Commercial Agreements and Competition Law After The Enactment of Competition Act 2010

Commercial Agreements and Competition Law After The Enactment of Competition Act 2010

The Competition Act 2010 (“Act”) which came into force on 1 January 2012, has a significant impact on how businesses should carry out their daily activities so as not to infringe the various anti-competition prohibitions under the Act. These anti-competition issues may arise from the day-to-day dealings with competitors, joint venture partners, manufacturers, wholesalers, suppliers, retailers, agents as well as customers, and will likely come under the scrutiny of competition authorities under the competition act. The Act applies to any commercial activity by any enterprise (including Government-linked companies) within and outside Malaysia which affects competition in any market in Malaysia; save for those sectors exempted by the Act in Schedule 1 (namely the industries under the purview of the Communications and Multimedia Act 1998, the Energy Commission Act 2001, the Petroleum Development Act 1974 as well as the Petroleum Regulations 1974). The regulator of the Act is the Malaysian Competition Commission (“MyCC”). Anti-Competitive Agreement Section 4 of the Act prohibits horizontal (enterprises operating at the same levels of the production or distribution chain, for e.g. competitors in the same market) and vertical (enterprises operating at the different levels of the production or distribution chain e.g. buyers and sellers at different stages of the production or distribution chain) agreements between enterprises where an agreement has the object or effect of significantly preventing, restricting or distorting competition in any market for goods or services. “Object” Section 4(2) of the Act states that horizontal agreements which have the object of price-fixing, market sharing, limiting or controlling production, market outlets or market access, technical or technological development, investment, and bid rigging are deemed to have the object of significantly preventing, restricting, or distorting competition in any market for goods or services. The MyCC will examine the actual common intentions of the parties to an agreement and also the aims pursued by the agreement in the light of the agreement’s economic context. If the “object” of an agreement is highly likely to have a significant anti-competitive effect, then the MyCC may find the agreement to have an anti-competitive “object”. The significance of this is that once an anti-competitive “object” is discovered, the MyCC does not have to examine or prove that the horizontal agreement will have an anti-competitive “effect” on the market; the mere existence of the object is sufficient to establish liability. “Effect” However, where an agreement (whether a horizontal or vertical agreement) does not have an anti-competitive “object”, the MyCC may continue to examine the agreement to see if it has an anti-competitive “effect”. In considering the effect of an agreement, it is important to analyse the effect of the agreement on the existing market in its economic context. In the absence of an anti-competitive object or effect, the agreement will fall outside the prohibitions under Section 4 of the Act. Types of anti-competitive agreements The MyCC has set out a non-exhaustive list of the types of agreements that may potentially be anti-competitive. Horizontal agreements that facilitate information (price or non-price) sharing, that restrict advertising and standardise agreements to set new standards or to sell new products, or that serve as a barrier to new entrants to the market will be investigated. Vertical agreements involving price restrictions such as setting minimum resale price maintenance, maximum price or recommended retail price which serves as a focal point for downstream collusion, may be anti-competitive, and the MyCC has made it clear that it will take a strong stance against these types of anti-competitive agreements. As such, setting a floor price would likely be anti-competitive whilst a ceiling price would not be, unless it serves as a focal point for downstream collusion. Other non-price vertical agreements such as tying and bundling agreements that require a buyer to buy all or most of its supplies from the seller, exclusive distribution agreements covering a geographic territory, exclusive customer allocation agreements as well as up-front access payments conditions may give rise to anti-competition concerns Saving the Agreement/Safe Harbour If, after having examined the agreement, it is found to be anti-competitive, it is still possible that the agreement may be “saved” in the following instances: (a) by establishing that the agreement does not significantly prevent, restrict or distort competition; The MyCC has indicated the following as a “safe harbour” if: the parties to the agreements are competitors (horizontal agreements) who are in the same market and their combined market share does not exceed 20%; or the parties to the agreement are not competitors (vertical agreements) and the market share held by each of the parties individually does not exceed 25%; (b) by establishing that the agreement is entitled to the relief of liability under Section 5 of the Act; In order to rely on this relief of liability, four conditions under Section 5 must be cumulatively satisfied, namely: (i) there must be significant identifiable technological, efficiency or social benefits directly arising from the agreement; (ii) the benefits could not reasonably have been provided by the parties to the agreement without the agreement having the effect of preventing, restricting or distorting competition; iii) the detrimental effect of the agreement on competition is proportionate to the benefits provided; and (iv) the agreement does not allow the enterprise concerned to eliminate competition completely in respect of a substantial part of the goods or services, The burden lies on the parties to the agreement to prove that the benefits gained are passed on to their consumers. The parties may rely on Section 5 to obtain an individual exemption. It can be also used as a defence if they are investigated by the MyCC, or in a civil suit brought by a member of the public; (c) by establishing whether the agreement might be eligible for exemption under an individual exemption; or If all the conditions under Section 5 are satisfied, the parties may apply to the MyCC for an individual exemption under Section 6 of the Act. The individual exemption granted by the MyCC may be subject to conditions, obligations and/or for a

Commercial Agreements and Competition Law After The Enactment of Competition Act 2010 Read More »

The New Trade Descriptions Act 2011: For Better or For Worse?

The New Trade Descriptions Act 2011: For Better or For Worse?

The Trade Descriptions Act 2011 (“New TDA”) has effectively come into force on 1 November 2011. The New TDA seeks to reform the law on trade descriptions by repealing the Trade Descriptions Act 1972 (“Old TDA”). The New Trade Description Act, like its predecessor, is enacted to promote good trade practices in the market by prohibiting false trade descriptions and false or misleading statements, conduct and practices in relation to the supply of goods and services, thereby protecting the interest of consumers. This article sets out to highlight some of the key provisions in the New TDA that every trademark owner should be aware of when protecting their trademarks in Malaysia. Methods to Enforce Trade Mark Rights In Malaysia, there are several methods in which a trademark owner can use to enforce and protect his rights. One of the most common methods is by initiating a civil action against the trademark infringers. However, a civil action is usually expensive, time-consuming and it places the burden of proof on the trademark owners to establish their case. In most cases, trademark owners usually prefer to stop the infringement immediately in the most cost-effective manner. As a first step, the trademark owners may issue a letter of demand or what is commonly known as a “cease and desist letter” to the infringers stating the trademark owners’ rights and how those rights have been infringed by the infringers. Issuing a cease and desist letter has proven to be quite effective in stopping further infringement. However, if the infringers deny their infringing acts, the trademark owners may resort to a civil action under the Trade Marks Act 1976. The trademark owners may also apply for an injunction to restrain further infringement or an order for delivery up of the infringing goods. In addition, the Trade Marks Act 1976 also provides a remedy for border measures control in which it allows the trademark owners (with the co-operation from the Royal Malaysian Customs Department) to stop the importation of counterfeit goods into the country. Similarly, like the Old Trade Description Act, the New Trade Description Act also provides for certain criminal remedies which would allow the trademark owners to stop their trademarks from being misused as false trade descriptions. Trademark owners may apply for a Trade Description Order (“TDO”), which is basically a declaratory order granted by the High Court declaring that a trademark or get-up used by an infringer amounts to a false trade description. The TDO empowers the officers from the Ministry of Domestic Trade, Cooperatives and Consumerism (“MDTCC”) to receive official complaints from the trademark owners and to raid and seize goods to which a false trade description has been applied. As a TDO is applied on an ex parte basis without having to call the respondent to the court, this lessens the procedures usually associated with injunctions and thus it saves substantial time and cost for the applicant. Besides, the enforcement and prosecution of the offence are carried out by the MDTCC at minimal cost to the registered trademark owners. As a result, an action under the TDO has proven to be the most commonly used and cost-effective way in curbing the sale of counterfeit goods. “Trade Description” A trademark owner should be aware that the New TDA expressly defines a “trade description” to include an indication, whether direct or indirect and by any means given, in respect of any goods or parts of goods relating to any rights in respect of trade marks registered under the Trade Marks Act 1976. A “false trade description” is a trade description which is false to a material degree or is misleading. Under the New TDA, it is an offence for any person who applies a false trade description to any goods as if the goods were subject to any rights relating to a registered trademark, or who supplies or offers to supply, exposes for supply or has in his possession, custody or control for supply any goods to which a false trade description is applied as if the goods were subject to any rights relating to a registered trademark. Upon conviction, the person will be liable to a hefty fine or imprisonment or both. Key Features of the New Trade Description Act (TDA) One of the key features under the New TDA is that only registered trademark owners in Malaysia can apply for a TDO. Previously, under the Old TDA, any trademark owners who have not registered their trademarks in Malaysia were allowed to enforce their common law trademark rights through the TDO. It appears that the Parliament has decided to restrict the right to the TDO, to only trademark owners who have registered their trademarks in Malaysia. No explanation was proffered for such a radical move. It should be noted that the Old TDA was modelled upon the UK Trade Descriptions Act 1968 and the UK law still allows common law trademark owners to enforce their rights regardless of whether they have a registered trademark in the UK. In the light of these changes, trademark owners should ensure that their trademarks are duly registered in Malaysia in order to protect their rights and interest. The validity period of a TDO has also been reduced from 5 years under the Old TDA to 1 year under the New TDA. Although the TDO can be renewed for a further period as may be determined by the court, this would incur further cost and time to the trademark owners. As such, the trademark owners who have obtained a TDO from the court should initiate the enforcement action as soon as possible rather than procrastinate. It should be noted that the TDO is only required in cases where the trademark or get-up used by the infringer is not identical but can be passed off as a registered trademark. A TDO, once granted, shall be taken as conclusive proof of a false trade description. Due to its far-reaching effects, the courts have held that a TDO will only

The New Trade Descriptions Act 2011: For Better or For Worse? Read More »

MAS-AirAsia Collaboration: Does It Breach The Competition Act 2010?

MAS-AirAsia Collaboration: Does It Breach The Competition Act 2010?

Malaysian Airline System Berhad (“MAS”), AirAsia Berhad (“AirAsia”) and AirAsia X Sdn Bhd (“Air Asia X”) have recently entered into a Comprehensive Collaboration Framework to explore opportunities to collaborate on a broad range of areas in which all parties will strive to complement each other’s businesses so as to leverage on their respective core competencies and optimise efficiency for the benefit of consumers. Does it violate the competition law? The collaboration has sparked concerns that the tie-up between the two airlines may result in a monopoly or anti-competitive behaviour in the airline industry. Many have expressed their worries that the collaboration may result in less frequent flights, limited travel options and that AirAsia may stop offering low price airfares since MAS is no longer a competitor to AirAsia. The collaboration agreement would only come into effect after a full competition analysis is completed and is in compliance with the applicable laws with regard to competition law in all the markets that the airlines operate in. It is noted that the recently-established Malaysian Competition Commission is also looking into the possible impact of the collaboration on the local market. Competition Act 2010 The Competition Act 2010 (“Act”) was passed by Parliament last year and is scheduled to come into force on 1 January 2012. The Act applies to any commercial activity by any company (including Government-linked companies) within and outside Malaysia which has an effect on competition in any market in Malaysia. Generally, competition law in most jurisdictions around the world covers three main pillars, prevention of anti-competitive agreements; abuse of a dominant position as well as a ruling against anti-competitive mergers and acquisitions. The Act does not, however, provide for regulation of mergers and acquisitions which may be anti-competitive, although the Government has not ruled out the possibility of introducing the third pillar in the future. Anti-Competitive Agreements The Act prohibits horizontal and vertical agreements between enterprises where an agreement has the object or effect of significantly preventing, restricting or distorting competition in any market for goods or services. Horizontal agreements which have the effect of price-fixing; market sharing; limit or control of production, market outlets or market access; bid rigging are deemed to be an anti-competitive agreement. Vertical agreements include tie-in arrangements and exclusive dealings which have the object of setting up barriers of entry against new entrants in a particular industry. Abuse of a Dominant Position Enterprises are prohibited from engaging in any conduct which amounts to an abuse of a dominant position such as imposing unfair purchase or selling price; limiting or controlling production, market outlets or market access, refusing to supply; applying discriminatory conditions that discourage new market entry; engaging in predatory behaviour towards competitors; or buying up scarce supplies in excess of the dominant enterprise’s own needs The Application of Competition Law to the Airline Industry In the airline industry, the typical competition issues include global alliances, tariff coordination, code-sharing, price-fixing, airport capacity and slots allocation, predatory pricing, frequent flyers programme, corporate discount schemes, travel agent commission, etc. These competition issues may arise from day-to-day dealings with competitors, joint venture partners, airport operators, suppliers, agents as well as customers, and will likely come under the scrutiny by the competition authority. In many countries, airlines have to seek permission and clearance from the competition authorities before they are allowed to form an alliance. The competition authorities will consider the terms of the agreement, the potential impact on the relevant markets as well as whether the alliance would result in excessive market domination. The competition authorities in many jurisdictions are generally supportive of airline alliances as they would result in cost savings, better connectivity and foster greater synergies between the airlines unless the alliances would result in the elimination of competition. Code-Sharing Code-sharing is an arrangement between two airlines where one airline (operating airline) allows another airline (marketing airline), as a codeshare partner, to market and sell tickets on the operating airline’s flights. The marketing airline that sells tickets under its own code does not actually operate the flight. While code-sharing agreements are generally permissible as they provide substantial benefits to consumers (such as seamless connections, greater network access and competitive airfares), some code-sharing agreements may give rise to anti-competitive concerns as the multiple displays of code-shared flights on computer screens push down other airlines’ flights to be displayed on following screens which may be missed by consumers searching for other flight options. It may also go beyond this and cover comprehensive integration of marketing and sharing of operational information that results in distortion of healthy competition practices. In this respect, AirAsia has dismissed the possibility of entering into a code-sharing agreement with MAS as it claims that both airlines operate on different market segments and different business models. It is believed that both airlines are likely to have a common understanding of joint planning, operating and coordinating routes, flight schedules and airfares. In Europe and the US, exemptions have been granted to a number of co-operation agreements between airlines on the condition that the whole arrangement benefits the customers of each party by providing access to a wider range of routes. Price Fixing In the past few years, dozens of airlines around the world have been slapped with hefty punishments by competition authorities for involvement in price-fixing cartels. For example, in November 2010, 11 airlines were fined a total of €799 million (about US$ 1.1 billion) by the European Commission for fixing the price of fuel and security surcharges on cargo flights worldwide over a six-year period from 1999 until 2006. Back at home, in July 2011, MAS announced that it would pay US$ 3.35 million to a number of freight forwarders in the US to settle claims alleging that MAS was involved in price fixing of airfreight shipping services and related surcharges, although MAS has denied any wrongdoing and claimed that the settlement was to allow MAS to focus its full attention on further strengthening its business and to keep its legal costs to

MAS-AirAsia Collaboration: Does It Breach The Competition Act 2010? Read More »

Snapshot of Legal Developments in the Q3 of 2016

Snapshot of Legal Developments in the Q3 of 2016

Here are some recent legal developments in the technology, media and telecommunications sphere in Malaysia that happened in Q3 of 2016. Bank Negara Malaysia (“BNM”) Discussion Paper on FinTech Regulatory Sandbox On 29 July 2016, BNM issued a discussion paper on FinTech regulatory sandbox (“Sandbox”), inviting financial institutions, FinTech companies and the public to provide general feedback on the discussion paper. Additionally, BNM has also requested interested stakeholders to comment on the adequacy, appropriateness and adequacy of the initially set eligibility criteria and to suggest alternatives to the current minimum standards. The introduction of the Sandbox would allow FinTech innovations to be deployed and experimented in a live environment within certain testing parameters and timeframe. Pursuant to the discussion paper, in order for a participant to participate in the Sandbox, the participant must show the following: (a) its solutions are genuinely innovative, novel, and not similar to solutions which are already available in the Malaysian market; (b) it intends to deploy its solutions on a commercial scale in Malaysia after its exit from the Sandbox; and (c) its solution will contribute to the development of Malaysia’s financial sector, bring about an enhancement to the Malaysian financial institutions, or significantly benefit the Malaysian economy or customers. Additionally, in determining an application to participate in the Sandbox and the extent of regulatory flexibilities to be granted to the participants, BNM has indicated that they would take into account various factors which include, but are not limited to the following: (a) the potential benefits of the proposed solution; (b) the potential risks and mitigating measures; and (c) the integrity, capability and track record of the participants. The test will run for a period not exceeding 12 months. Participants may extend the testing period by submitting a written application to BNM no later than 30 days before the expiry of the testing period. At the end of the testing period, BNM will develop a transition plan for the deployment of the solution on a commercial scale in Malaysia upon successful testing. On the other hand, if the test fails or is discontinued, BNM will then consult the participants and develop an exit strategy for them. Legality of Airbnb Services Recently, it has been reported that some hoteliers had complained to the authorities that Airbnb services were illegal as the online platform allows the public to provide short-term rentals on residential premises to tourists for business purposes. The Malaysian Association of Hotels has indicated that not only this causes unwanted disturbance to the neighbours of Airbnb hosts (“Hosts”), users of Airbnb services are not adequately protected as the Hosts are not required to adhere to any safety requirements such as ensuring their customers against any risks or installing safety equipment on their premises. Additionally, unlike the Malaysian Homestay Programme, where the locals are authorized to offer tourists the unique lifestyle of rural villages, Airbnb operates without any licence or approval from the authorities, and the Hosts are not required to pay or collect taxes. As such, the hoteliers have urged the Government to regulate such services. In June 2016, the Penang Municipal Council (“MBPP”) issued a number of fines to several Hosts in Penang for providing homestay or lodging services to tourists without a valid licence issued under section 4 of the Municipal Council of Penang Island (Trade, Business and Industries) By-Laws 1991. Some of the Hosts have challenged this decision on the ground that since they do not provide homestay nor hotel services, there is no licence required. In August 2016, the Urban Wellbeing, Housing and Local Government Ministry (“KPKT”) was quoted by the media as saying that Airbnb’s home sharing service was not illegal and no licence was required. The KPKT, Tourism and Culture Ministry and Malaysia Productivity Corporation have also announced that there are no immediate plans to draft any new law on the matter or to issue any licences similar to those granted to hotels. It remains to be seen whether there will be further developments in this area. Announcement of the Fees for Spectrum Reallocation In Q1 of 2016, the Government announced that spectrum for the telecommunications industry would be reallocated in a move to optimize revenue. It was reported that this move was made pursuant to the Budget 2016 recalibrations. Soon after, the Malaysian Communications and Multimedia Commission (“MCMC”) announced that the 900 MHz and 1,800 MHz frequency bands would be reallocated among the four major telcos, namely Maxis, Celcom, Digi and U Mobile. On 31 August 2016, the MCMC announced the respective fees for the reallocation of spectrum in the 900 MHz and 1800 MHz bands. The MCMC states that the fee of spectrums will be determined per block of 2 x 5MHz in both 900 MHz and 1800 MHz frequency bands. It was reported that the spectrum fee is structured in two parts. First is a one-off payment for the price component which is determined at RM499,725,000.00 per block for the 900 MHz band and RM217,770,000 per block for the 1800 MHz band. The second part is an annual maintenance fee that is payable annually. The assignment will be valid for 15 years, with an implementation date set on 1 July 2017. Furthermore, to prevent the cost of spectrum assignment from trickling down to the consumers, the MCMC added that it is a condition of reallocation that telcos must offer packages that are cheaper than what is currently being offered to their subscribers. Establishment of 1st Special Cyber Court The purpose of this initiative is to arm the judicial system with sufficient and adequate means of handling cybercrime offences, such as hacking, online fraud/scamming, botnet, online defamation, sedition and harassment, web-defacement, stealing of online information, cyber gambling and pornography, etc. The Special Cyber Court will deploy specialised and trained judges to hear cases relating to cybercrime. The Special Cyber Court is expected to function in the same way like any other special courts such as those that are already in place to deal with intellectual property,

Snapshot of Legal Developments in the Q3 of 2016 Read More »

Net Neutrality and Open Internet Rules

Net Neutrality and Open Internet Rules

The issue of the need to maintain net neutrality and an open Internet concept has been a considerable debate for years, with the most recent development being the landmark ruling of the US Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit on 14 June 2016 in favour of net neutrality. Net neutrality is a principle which requires all Internet Service Providers (“ISPs”) to treat all sources of online content equally and provide all consumers with the right to access the content on a non-discriminatory basis. The idea behind net neutrality is that the Internet should remain open and neutral with uninhibited access to online content without the ISPs being allowed to block, impair or establish fast/slow lanes on the delivery of online content to consumers. However, ISPs argue that they have the right to optimise the use of the network resources and that Internet traffic or traffic prioritisation measures are necessary to ensure a reasonable quality of service standard for all Internet users, especially as Internet traffic continues to grow. The Open Internet Rules in the US In the US, the Federal Communications Commission (“FCC”) has developed Open Internet Rules, which are designed to protect free expression, innovation and economic growth on the Internet, as well as to promote investment in broadband networks. The Open Internet Rules are also intended to ensure that consumers and businesses alike have access to a fast, fair and open Internet. The FCC’s Open Internet Rules came into force on 12 June 2015 and apply to both fixed and mobile broadband Internet access services, which is classified as a “telecommunications service” by the FCC. Essentially, the Open Internet Rules set out five bright-line rules, as follows: (a) No blocking: ISPs are not allowed to block access to lawful online content, applications, services or non-harmful devices; (b) No throttling: ISPs are not allowed to impair or degrade lawful Internet traffic on the basis of content, applications, services or non-harmful devices; (c) No paid prioritisation: ISPs are not allowed to favour some lawful Internet traffic over other lawful traffic in exchange for consideration of any kind (in other words, ISPs are not allowed to provide “fast lanes” to certain content/service providers who are willing to pay in exchange for fast lanes); (d) No unreasonable interference: ISPs are not allowed to interfere unreasonably with their end users’ ability to use broadband Internet access services, or with their edge providers’ ability to make lawful online content, applications, services and devices available to end users; and (e) Enhanced transparency: ISPs must publicly disclose accurate information regarding the network management practices, performance and commercial terms of its broadband Internet access services to allow end users to make informed choices and for content, application and service providers to develop, maintain and market Internet offerings. As many as 4 million Americans have overwhelmingly voted to support the FCC’s initiative in keeping a free and fair Internet. Many tech giants like Google, Facebook and Netflix have also rallied in favour of the Open Internet Rules. It is said that without net neutrality, ISPs may choose to deliver certain online content at a slower speed, for example, making the video streaming on Netflix or YouTube buffer, unless they pay extra to get in the fast lane. However, the Open Internet Rules were not welcomed by the ISPs and they brought a case against the FCC. They argued, amongst others, that as broadband is an information service, as opposed to a telecommunications service, hence the FCC lacked statutory authority to create the Open Internet Rules and impose them on ISPs. They also argued that some of the rules were unconstitutionally vague and ran afoul of the US Constitution. The US Court of Appeals rejected the ISPs’ arguments and held in favour of the Open Internet Rules. The court held that: FCC had the authority to reclassify broadband as a telecommunications service. This was based on the evidence that consumers generally viewed broadband as essential communication and information platform that transmits data of their own choosing to their desired destination, as opposed to a mere information service; interconnection arrangements are derivative of the broadband Internet access service and hence, they could be regulated under the law; FCC had the authority to come up with measures to encourage the deployment of broadband infrastructure and rules to govern ISPs’ treatment of Internet traffic; and the Open Internet Rules generally require ISPs to offer a standardised service that transmits data on a non-discriminatory basis. Such equal access rule did not run afoul of the First Amendment to the US Constitution (which affirms the right to freedom of expression). This decision affirmed the US Government’s view that broadband is a utility that should be made equally available to all consumers, rather than a luxury that does not require government supervision. This decision marks a landslide victory for net neutrality in the US and an enormous win for consumers. With this decision, all ISPs must treat all Internet traffic equally, and this assures a level playing field for all online content and benefit both consumers and online content developers alike. President Obama – The Man behind the Push for Net Neutrality Rules The current US President, Barack Obama, is known as an ardent supporter of net neutrality. He has been instrumental in calling on the FCC to take up the strongest possible rules to protect net neutrality. In an open letter to the FCC in November 2014, he wrote, “an open Internet is essential to the American economy, and increasingly to our very way of life. By lowering the cost of launching a new idea, igniting new political movements, and bringing communities closer together, it has been one of the most significant democratizing influences the world has even known… The Internet has been one of the greatest gifts our economy and our society has ever known… there is no higher calling than protecting an open, accessible and free Internet.” Net Neutrality Concept in Malaysia & ASEAN In ASEAN, Singapore’s telecommunications

Net Neutrality and Open Internet Rules Read More »

Facebook – 10 Years of Legal Issues and Still Counting

Facebook – 10 Years of Legal Issues and Still Counting

Facebook, arguably the world’s most successful and influential social networking site, has just turned 10 last month. On 4 February 2004, Mark Zuckerberg launched The Facebook from his Harvard dorm room. Originally intended to just serve as a social networking site exclusively for university and college students in the United States, Facebook has since grown by leaps and bounds to become the largest social networking site in the world. Facebook has attracted 1.23 billion users worldwide so far, and reportedly earned $7.9 billion in revenue in 2013. Facebook made a grand entrance into Nasdaq stock exchange when it went public in May 2012 by having one of the largest initial public offerings in Internet history, and it continues to make headlines every now and then, the latest being the acquisition of WhatsApp for a whopping $19 billion (Facebook bought Instagram for $1 billion in April 2012, just before it went public). This article is not intended to talk about how awesome Facebook is, or the benefits or changes that Facebook has brought to our daily lives (for better or worse). This article is meant to set out the various social and legal implications arising from the rapid growth and widespread use of Facebook in the last 10 years. In this article, reference will be made to Facebook’s Statement of Rights and Responsibilities (“Facebook’s Terms”), which is essentially the main document that sets out the terms of use that governs the relationship between Facebook with users and others who interact with Facebook. Violation of any provisions under Facebook’s Terms will result in the individual’s Facebook account being terminated or suspended. Posting third party content Very often, we find users posting contents such as text, graphics, photos or videos not belonging to theirs on Facebook without realising that such actions could potentially amount to infringement of copyright law which can result in both criminal and civil liability. According to Facebook’s Terms, users are not allowed to post content that infringes or violates someone else’s rights or otherwise violates the law. Facebook has set up a special tool to enable users to report to Facebook if their intellectual property rights have been infringed by other users. Facebook has the right to take down the infringing content upon receipt of such a report. It also states that repeated or continuous infringement of other’s intellectual property rights may result in the individual’s Facebook account being terminated or disabled by Facebook. Who owns and controls your content? When Facebook first started, it tried to claim ownership over all contents posted on Facebook. This had, of course, resulted in much criticism, which prompted Facebook to change its terms of use. The Facebook’s Terms now state that all users own all of the content and information they post on Facebook, and they give Facebook a non-exclusive, transferable, sub-licensable, royalty-free, worldwide license to use any content that users post on Facebook. Facebook also tried to remove a sentence from the Facebook’s Terms saying that “the license will automatically end when the user removes the content”, and this had again caused an uproar, forcing Facebook to restore that particular sentence. Disclosure of sensitive or confidential information The ease of posting information online and the desire to share (or show-off) information have resulted in instances where users (knowingly or unintentionally) leak sensitive or confidential information (such as trade secret, corporate intelligence or financial disclosure in violation of securities laws) to the public. We all know what once information gets published on the Internet, it will never get deleted. The instantaneous and far-reaching nature of social networking makes it difficult for users to recall information that has gone public. The implication can be very serious because for information to remain confidential, it must have the necessary “quality of confidence”. The confidential information will lose its confidential nature the moment it is disclosed to the public. Defamation Lawsuits alleging defamation based on content posted on social networking sites such as Facebook are on the rise. A defamation claim may be actionable when a person has published words which connote any imputation which may tend “to lower the other person in the estimation of right-thinking members of society generally”, “cut him off from society” or “to expose him to hatred, contempt or ridicule”. Courts have ruled that posting on Facebook amounts to a publication to the world at large. Facebook’s Terms require users not to post content that is hate speech, threatening, or pornographic; incites violence, or contains nudity or graphic or gratuitous violence. Users should, therefore, avoid making statements that are harmful, offensive or inflammatory. Cyber-stalking and cyber-bullying Stalking and bullying that used to only take place in real life, are now also happening on the Internet, particularly on social networking sites. Many users tend to post too much of personal information on their profile pages, which enables anyone with access to that information to stalk them. What is more worrying is, many users are not aware that everything posted on Facebook is by default made public, and it is up to the users to restrict the access to the information to just friends or family. Cyber-bullying can take many forms, such as posting hurtful or threatening messages on users’ page, spreading false rumours online, starting pages to ridicule or spread gossip about individuals, or circulating embarrassing or compromising pictures about individuals. It has been reported in the newspapers that many teenagers have committed suicide or suffered from anxiety and depression due to cyber-stalking and cyber-bullying that they had experienced on social networking sites. Facebook’s Terms explicitly state that users are not allowed to bully, intimidate or harass any other users on Facebook, or use Facebook to do anything unlawful, misleading, malicious or discriminatory. Electronic discovery Lawyers and prosecutors have resorted to fishing for evidence from information posted on Facebook. Some have even applied for court orders to obtain such information. In one instance, a photo of a wife hugging an unidentified man on Facebook was accepted as evidence to support a

Facebook – 10 Years of Legal Issues and Still Counting Read More »

Snapshot of Legal Developments – Q2 of 2016

Snapshot of Legal Developments – Q2 of 2016

This marks a new series of articles that I am writing, with the aim of providing you with a snapshot of important legal developments to keep you informed of the significant legal developments in the technology, media and telecommunications sphere in Malaysia on a quarterly basis. Issuance of Compounding Regulations pursuant to the Personal Data Protection Act 2010 On 15 March 2016, the Commissioner issued the Personal Data Protection (Compounding of Offences) Regulations 2016 (“Compounding Regulations”). The Compounding Regulations provides a list of offences which are prescribed to be “compoundable offences”. For offences which are compoundable, the Commissioner may offer data users an opportunity to pay a monetary penalty (which penalty can be up to half of the maximum fine stipulated in the Personal Data Protection Act 2010 (“PDPA”) within the time period stipulated in the offer. If no payment is received within the stipulated period, prosecution for the offence will be instituted against the data user. It is important to note that only some and not all offences under the PDPA and its regulations are compoundable. The issuance of the Compounding Regulations points to the focus of the Commissioner and the Personal Data Protection Department (“PDP Department”) moving to the next phase of implementation of the PDPA, namely investigation and enforcement. Most data users would favour the use of compounds as it is likely to reduce the penalties for not complying with the PDPA significantly, as well as save both the prosecution’s and alleged offender’s time and costs, as parties would be spared the time and expense of court proceedings. Malaysia to step up cybersecurity measures in the capital market and national defence sectors On 21 March 2016, the Securities Commission Malaysia (“SC”) published a consultation paper seeking public feedback on the proposed regulatory framework relating to the management of cyber security risk by capital market participants. The SC recognises that with the increased dependency on information technology and Internet connectivity, there is a need to put in place cyber security policies and procedures to safeguard and protect the confidentiality, integrity and availability of information systems used by capital market participants. Sound management of cybersecurity risk has been identified as a critical component to further strengthen the resilience of the Malaysian capital markets. Towards this objective, the SC intends to introduce regulatory requirements to guide the capital market participants to achieve a certain state of cybersecurity resilience. The SC recommends that the board of directors of capital market participants set a clear direction and give adequate priority in their respective board’s agenda for the effective management of cybersecurity risk and require their senior management to develop and implement appropriate cybersecurity frameworks (which includes policies, procedures, awareness programmes and risk reporting mechanisms) throughout their organisations. On the defence front, the Deputy Defence Minister Datuk Seri Mohd Johari Baharum, during his keynote address at the Cyber Security Conference in conjunction with the 15th Defence Services Asia Exhibition and Conference on 20 April 2016, proposed a three-pronged approach to enhance cybersecurity in Malaysia. The three-pronged approach consists of: reorientation of the design philosophy of the Information Communications Technology (ICT) systems, in particular focusing on cyber defence systems to ensure all computing systems reflect uniform reliance; establishment of inter-disciplinary centres, specifically on the need to connect academia, the private sector, national laboratories and the government in sharing information and offering innovative and creative solutions; and getting the military defence and security community to provide “leadership by example” and “provide support to the national and global efforts in meeting cybersecurity challenges to the defence and security domains”. The above announcement was made in response to the rising threat of cyber-attacks in Malaysia. Cyber Security Malaysia (a government agency tasked with being Malaysia’s Cyber Security Reference and Specialist Centre) reported that 11,900 cybersecurity-related cases were recorded in 2015, as compared to only 1,038 cases recorded in 2007, which may lead to some legislative reforms to bolster and/or to introduce new legislation that deals with cybersecurity threats to Malaysia’s critical information infrastructure. Land Public Transport Commission to regulate ride-sharing and taxi-booking apps by Q4 of 2016 Following an endorsement by the Special Economic Committee chaired by the Prime Minister of Malaysia, ride-sharing and taxi-booking apps such as Uber and Grab may be subject to a new regulatory framework to be introduced by the Land Public Transport Commission (“SPAD”) by Q4 of 2016. This proposal was made in response to the rising tide of a new form of competition introduced by these third party ride-sharing and taxi-booking apps and complaints filed by the incumbent taxi companies. Although no draft of the regulatory framework has yet been circulated, it is understood that for the conventional taxi industry, a profit-sharing concept or guaranteed percentage of the day’s income for the taxi drivers will be introduced. For the private car drivers, they would be required to obtain a public service vehicle license and register themselves with SPAD for vetting purposes, before they are allowed to offer their services. Private car drivers are also required to send their vehicles for annual inspections and take up passenger insurance coverage, much like what taxi drivers are currently required to adhere to. It is also understood that this third-party ride-sharing and taxi-booking companies may be subject to local taxation laws when the regulatory framework is introduced, as the government has realised that there is a potentially massive outflow of the Ringgit due to the widespread use of these booking apps. Several laws, such as the Land Public Transport Act 2010, Road Transport Act 1987 and Communications and Multimedia Act 1998, will need to be amended to facilitate these new changes. The Amendment Bills may be tabled in Parliament during its sitting in October 2016, and “if everything goes well, a new dawn of taxi industry may begin the end of the year,” SPAD chairman said. Spectrum reallocation in the telecommunications industry On 27 January 2016, the Prime Minister of Malaysia, Dato Sri Mohd Najib bin Razak, during the Budget 2016 recalibration, announced that

Snapshot of Legal Developments – Q2 of 2016 Read More »

WiFi Piggybacking – Is It Legal?

WiFi Piggybacking – Is It Legal?

It was recently reported that the Malaysian Communications and Multimedia Commision (“MCMC”) had received six complaints regarding the supply and sale of devices that can hack into WiFi connections. Three cases have since been sentenced by the courts and the other three will soon be brought to the courts soon. Most of the WiFi hacking incidents were carried out by using devices such as WiFi booster and WiFi cracker, which can amplify signals to attract WiFi signals within a distance of one to three kilometres. The MCMC said that a person who uses, has in possession or sells this type of non-standard equipment or device can be charged under Section 239 of the Communications and Multimedia Act 1998 (“CMA”), and will be fined up to RM100,000 and/or jailed up to 2 years upon conviction. A person who possesses, obtains or creates an equipment or device designed to fraudulently use or obtain any network facilities, network service, applications service or content applications service can also be charged under Section 232 of the CMA, which upon conviction, will be fined up to RM300,000 and/or jailed up to 3 years. There is also another form of “stealing” WiFi connections without having to use any equipment or device such as WiFi booster or WiFi cracker. It has been established that using another person’s unsecured WiFi connection without his or her consent and knowledge is known as “piggybacking” or “mooching”. If a person’s WiFi connection is not secured by a password, any person can actually connect to the account, without the person’s consent and knowledge. WiFi piggybacking normally happens when a person uses his neighbour’s WiFi connection without permission, or when a person sitting in a car near a WiFi hotspot to access the WiFi connection. The issue on WiFi piggybacking remains controversial. Some argue that it is harmless, because it is no different to sitting behind another passenger on a train, and reading his newspaper over his shoulder, or enjoying the music a neighbour is playing in his backyard. Others, however, argue that it is unethical, because it is akin to entering a home just because the door is unlocked, or hanging on the outside of a bus to get a free ride (Source: Wikipedia – Piggybacking (Internet Access)). Let’s take a look at what has happened around the world in respect of WiFi piggybacking. In the United States, most of the states prohibit unauthorised access to computer networks which include open WiFi networks. In 2005, a man in Florida was charged with unauthorised access to a computer network because he was using a resident’s WiFi connection from a car parked outside. In 2007, a man in Michigan was fined for using a cafe’s WiFi connection from a car parked nearby to check his email every day. In Singapore, a 17 years old teenager was arrested for tapping into his neighbour’s WiFi connection. Apparently, he went outside his house to piggyback on any available WiFi connection after his mother had confiscated his computer modem. He was seen chatting online when a passerby asked what he was doing, became suspicious, and later called the police. He pleaded guilty and was sentenced to 18 months’ probation under the Computer Misuse Act. In the United Kingdom, a man was also convicted for dishonestly obtaining an electronic communication service when he was found repeatedly trying to gain access to a neighbour’s WiFi connection with a laptop from his car. In Malaysia, no one has been arrested or charged for WiFi piggybacking so far. Our Computer Crimes Act 1997 is very similar to the Computer Misuse Act in Singapore and the United Kingdom, which means WiFi piggybacking could potentially constitute a criminal offence under Malaysian law. Section 3 of the Computer Crimes Act 1997 states that a person who: causes a computer to perform any function with intent to secure access to any program or data held in any computer; the access he intends to secure is unauthorised; and he knows at the time when he causes the computer to perform the function that that is the case, will be fined up to RM50,000 and/or jailed up to 5 years upon conviction. This section is also targeted at hackers who hack into other’s computer network or system. One peculiar feature of this Computer Crimes Act 1997 is that it has extra-territorial scope. The Computer Crimes Act 1997 states that regardless of the person’s nationality or citizenship, where an offence is committed by the person in any place outside Malaysia, in which the computer, program or data that he accessed was in Malaysia, or capable of being connected to or sent to or used by or with a computer in Malaysia, he may be charged under the Computer Crimes Act 1997 as if it was committed at any place within Malaysia. What this means is that a foreign hacker may be charged in Malaysia if he hacks into a computer, program or data in Malaysia. It will be interesting to see how the enforcement authorities will enforce the law against people who piggyback on other’s WiFi connection, especially with the Government’s plan to increase public WiFi hotspot to make it freely available to the people across the nation. From a technological point of view, it might do no harm to you sharing your WiFi connection with others. However, from a legal perspective, that may attract several problems. For example, sharing your home WiFi connection with neighbours may violate your Internet Service Provider’s terms of service. That is because usually home WiFi package only allows WiFi connection to be shared within home users only (as opposed to those business WiFi package used by cafés, offices and shopping malls which allows them to share with the public). Another legal implication that may arise from allowing WiFi connection freely available is that you may be liable for the conduct of the person using your WiFi connection since you are the subscriber of the WiFi connection. While it is clear that unauthorised access

WiFi Piggybacking – Is It Legal? Read More »

Responsibilities of Executor:

  • Apply for and extract the grant of probate.
  • Make arrangements for the funeral of the deceased.
  • Collect and make an accurate inventory of the deceased’s assets.
  • Settling the debts and obligations of the deceased.
  • Distributing the assets.

Note for Digital Executor:
If you wish to leave your digital assets to certain people in your Will, there are important steps that need to be taken to ensure that your wishes can be carried out:

  • Keep a note of specific instructions on how to access your username and password of your digital asset.
  • You are advised to store these private and confidential information in a USB stick, password management tool or write them down.
  • Please inform your executor or a trusted person of the whereabouts of the tools so that they will have access to your digital asset.